I’ve got a new project. Finches. It’s hard for a novice to diffrinchiate the finchery and I intend to learn.
Back when I despaired of recognizing any birds at all, my friend Linder told me “Just think. If you learn just one bird a year, you’ll know forty birds by the time you’re dead.” That was a bunch of years ago. But the point is, if you get your noticers sharpened up, your knowledge begins to accumulate. Take, for example, the lesser goldfinch, whose existence I had not even suspected ten years ago, even though we have squadrons of them in the yard all year long, thick as mosquitoes, and my yard isn’t that big.
Sarah Swanson, who has patiently been my bird guide for years, was the first to point out a purple finch for me. She pointed out the tail. She pointed out the bill. She pointed out the wing bars. Did I see it? No, honey. I didn’t see any of that. It looked like a house finch to me.
We have gobs of house finches. They’re your basic brown and white stripey numbers with pink heads and décolletage. And there’s a lot of variation, once you start looking. Sometimes they’re not pink at all, but an unrepentant orange. Some of them rock more color than others. But the other day I spied a finch that looked a little more adamant about its hue than usual, and I snapped some pictures. HUH! Could this finally be my elusive purple? I looked it up. There are plenty of sites that show you the differences although they all caution that it’s easy to get it wrong. I stared at my photos and just couldn’t quite pull the trigger on an ID. And then I thought: why spend all this time farting around looking stuff up like a self-educating grownup when I could just put the photo on my Facebook page and have my friends tell me in, like, two minutes?
And solid bird ID is what you can count on when you have hundreds of authentic birders on your friends list. The votes began to come in hard and fast. You’re always going to get a guess from your non-birder friends (“Grandma used to call them dingflappers”) because everyone likes to be helpful, but pretty soon you get a good consensus. I was hoping to hear from Sarah because she can pull an ID from a fuzzy shot of butt feathers exiting the frame in heavy fog, and I’ve seen her do it. Plus she’s local.
Anyway, exciting news! It came up Purple Finch, just as I had hoped. Chris, Cindy, Katy, Barrett, Mimi, Kim, Néna, all agreed and gave the reasons why, and Julie Zickefoose, in whose brain I store a lot of my memory, tied it all up with a half dozen unmistakable field marks, and seemed to have more ammunition on her belt yet, but ran out of typing.
And that’s when it occurred to me: I have finches. I have a seed feeder. I have a Project!
Not much of a Project, you say? For a creative woman with nothing but time? Fie. Smoking cigarettes and watching Captain Kangaroo is all well and good, but I need to branch out.
I’ve got a feeder right outside my window. I’ll devote a day just looking at tails. I’ll get the tail down. I’ll spend another day looking at primary feathers. There will be a Bill Day. And when a purple finch makes an appearance, my HUH will turn into an AHA. I will be able to astonish uninterested passersby with my expertise. (It’s a low bar. One of my neighbors mistook a flicker for a pheasant, so.)
I’ma bag me another purple.
And once I have all that down, I’m going for the gold star. The females. The males, per standard bird code of conduct, are the more decorative of the sexes, same as in humans, whereas the females just try to get the job done without drawing undue attention to themselves.
And as a result, there is a whole sisterhood of female songbird species that all look exactly the same, if you’re not paying attention. They’re fine with that. They’ve got stuff to do. But—for my project—it does appear the female purple finch distinguishes herself from her house finch counterpart. She has a distinct white eyebrow, which allows her to look askance at things. And she has brown streaks in her underpants. Which might very well be true, but it’s still a little rude to point it out.
Oh. Underparts. That’s different. Never mind.
Distinct lack of finches around here or maybe I just don’t see them. Lots of woodpeckers, tho, and nuthatches and chickadees. My goal for the summer this year is to get the orioles to come to the feeders.
I’d settle for getting an oriole to make me a sock.
Smiling broadly.
I battle another problem. There are some birds whose differences I can clearly see, but I cannot remember what difference goes with what branch of the family. I am sure that that is feuding words too….
Oh. Learning a bird and getting it to stay learned are two different things for those of us who are…differently abled.
Well, thanks for that earworm! Although of all the ones lurking about ready to burrow in, that one’s fairly benign.
Laughing out loud about the brown streaks, rude or not.
Back now to being finchy here at home, including the glance askance.
Speaking of earworms, I have woken up every day for the last three weeks humming a Haydn string quartet that I haven’t actually listened to for maybe forty years. Classy, sure, but what the hell?
I remember vividly the first time I saw a Lesser Goldfinch. It was a male, perched on a dandelion stem, eating seeds off the fluffy seed head. The stem didn’t even bend. I was impressed by how tiny and yellow it was.
I have watched and admired the very same thing.
Here’s the thing, though. I am rarely quite certain enough about the males to make a loud public declaration on the subject, but if the FEMALES are there, then I can be certain. Because I can tell the females apart easily, so I figure if a female purple finch is hanging around with some pinkish reddish purplish finch, he’s probably an honest to god purple finch. Unless she’s a finchy floozy.
Don’t ask me how many times I wondered what ALL THE BROWN BIRDS hanging out with the male red-winged blackbirds are.
At least around here, it’s not the male humans that are more “decorative.” Unless one calls stubble, big-ass cargo shorts (even in winter), and an extra-large t-shirt (even on a skinny guy) and sneakers “decorative.” Contrary-wise, the females (now, I’m talkin’ about the young uns) try to emulate the skinny with big boobs, big hair, skirts short enough that the world can be your gynecologist (or tight-fitting yoga pants… so, ditto) and obvious makeup and false eyelashes look that apparently they think is the way to go. So, obviously, in humans, it is the opposite way of “finding a mate” than the birds. Which no doubt explains why humans are so fucked up. I once encountered a young, VERY tan woman at a party. She and her cohorts were talking about her tan. I chimed in, “Yes, but you will get really old-looking and wrinkled when you get to be my age.” She replied, “Yes, but I want to look hot NOW!” I just shook my head. They don’t realize that just being young makes them hot looking. As a devout sunscreen user since I found out in my twenties how bad the sun is for you, I remain pale and proud. And unwrinkly
I’m persuaded that the styles are different in different parts of the country. The kind of woman you described does not live within five miles of downtown.
I’ve always preferred pale women, but never liked paleness on myself. No, I don’t understand it.
Jeremy, I used to tan as heavily as I could when I was young, before all the info came out about how damaging it is. Once THAT bit of news cam out, I totally swore off tanning, and used as much an SPF as I could find that didn’t break me out. Even as a young thing, I was more concerned with the future than I was with the present. It’s a blessing… and a curse. (As far as pale goes, I always thought Bernadette Peters had the most beautiful skin.)
I never took a spectrophotometer to Ms. Peters, but she sure looks good!
I don’t know what color I am. I have flannel.
My mum used to keep finches in a huge aviary in her backyard, canaries were in there too. I haven’t the foggiest memory of what they looked like but I remember some were called zebra finches and all the canaries were yellow.
Here in my own yard, according to my bird book, female blackbirds are actually brown and I saw one this morning, hopping up towards the water dish.
ZEBRA FINCHES! I wish!
Fun fact: One in seven birds in the world is a finch! Trivial Pursuit taught me that in the 80s and I’ve dined on it ever since.
Yeah, don’t look it up now by all means. Not that I’m doubting you. I have no idea.
Like many more shallow birders, I’m less excited by the drab females. (Check out Wilson’s phalaropes – roles are switched there.) And I ignore juvenile gulls, too. Because I can’t hold details in my hard drive, I can’t immediately recognize many other birds that I’m “supposed” to know, at least not without a check with Cornell or Peterson’s. But, you go, girl. You’ll be a Sarah before you know it!
Oh no I won’t. That’s why I like to have one in the stable.
Wahahahaha!!! I LOLed at: “Julie Zickefoose, in whose brain I store a lot of my memory, tied it all up with a half dozen unmistakable field marks, and seemed to have more ammunition on her belt yet, but ran out of typing.” Hey. Just tryin’ to give you some tips you won’t find in the guide, because in between smokin’ cigarettes and watching Captain Kangaroo, pretty much all I do is scrutinize birds for things you won’t find in the field guide. This post: smokin’ hot, so good. Keep writing, Murrbaby. Honored to keep a store of your memory, but I think it’s time to back both ours up to an external hard drive, cuz the Cloud is hoodoo stuff.
But…but…you ARE my external hard drive!
You’re almost an expert.
I point and scream, “Birds!” and expect applause.
I’m clapping on the inside.
I’m not exactly an expert at the bird identification thing, but feel free to email me if you have trouble telling a Northern Flicker from a Bluejay. I can help you out there, and I’m glad to do it. Fair exchange for ‘Now don’t tell me I’ve nuthin’ to do’ owning my brain box the rest of today.
I will admit that is fair.
Looking at an entire page of nearly-identical female sparrows in Sibley is almost enough to make me give up on even attempting to ID female birds. Also, the sexes of the American robin and the western scrub jay appear very similar. To me, anyway. And don’t even get me started on hawks and vultures.
Just recently one of our white-crowned sparrows figured out how to hang onto and eat from the sock full of Guizotia abyssinica seeds (which some call thistle, which they’re not, and which some marketing genius decided to call “nyjer”), but when the sparrows aren’t in the way the sock is covered with Lesser goldfinches. They can empty that thing in under a week. A few months ago our first spotted towhee showed up, and seems to have decided to stay. California towhees all the time. Anna’s hummingbird’s year-round, rufous hummingbirds seasonally, passing through. Some years ago Marsha spotted our first hooded oriole hanging upside-down, picking drips off a leaky hummingbird feeder. Now we hang a separate feeder just for them in the summer, which they sometimes share with Bullock’s orioles (which we can identify because they wear eyeliner). I try to keep a steady supply of suet in the yard, and daily tear up a slice of bread and leave that on the lawn with some almonds to make the jays happy. Sometimes crows show up to join the feast, sometimes they don’t, but they don’t seem to be using their size to scare off the little birds — in fact they look very wary. We had a feeder full of mixed seeds, but had no good place to hang it after the crumbling pergola was torn down, so I pitched it rather than keep it in the garage until the smell brought mice. Some birds picked their favorite seeds out carefully, others scooped the stuff they didn’t like gleefully onto the grass, where the mourning doves (and sometimes pigeons) were happy to find it. I wanted to put up an owl house, but I read that one shouldn’t host owls before persuading all of one’s neighbors to not use rodenticides, so, having no desire to go door-to-door persuading our neighbors of anything, I dropped that idea. But owls have moved into the neighborhood somewhere anyway, and I love to hear them calling in the evening.
In his book “Living Mammals of the World” naturalist Ivan Sanderson, in writing about the cane-rat (a.k.a. grasscutter or, in pidgin, cutting-grass) said it makes a noise like that of the Indonesian brain-fever bird. He described it as a sound like a pebble being dropped onto outdoor ice in winter, or “boing.” He wrote that the brain-fever bird is called that because the irregular frequency of the boings can drive a person nuts, and that people in Indonesia sometimes spend hours betting on the interval before the next boing. Yesterday I googled the brain-fever bird and found absolutely nothing in the description or the recorded calls that matched his description. Boing.
I shall end my treatise with “A Wonderful Bird Is The Pelican” by Dixon Lanier Merritt (which I thought was by Hilaire Belloc until I looked it up just now):
A wonderful bird is the pelican,
His bill will hold more than his belican,
He can take in his beak
Enough food for a week
But I’m damned if I see how the helican!
Your writing always amuses and informs me. I read that birds’ eyesight is not only in our range of the spectrum, but slides into the ultraviolet. It’s said that this is why birds that look alike to us (blue jays, robins) can tell the sexes apart; they may see something we don’t. A lot of nocturnal creatures slide into the infrared spectrum (bats, raccoons). The ONLY creature that comprises not only our visual spectrum, but also some ultraviolet AND infrared? The goldfish! WTF? How do they rate?
Interesting! I didn’t know about that. You inspired me to look it up — there’s a good article at https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/50/10/854/233996 but I’m guessing you’ve already read it.
If I ever feel like taking a week off I know this blog will be in good hands with only the slightest of nudges.
We may keep ourselves entertained and busy, but we can’t write the way you do!
Besides, we need a topic to digress from.
I thought when I read the lead that we were going to learn about UNDERPANTS on birds. I did read Murr’s entire post and all comments. I never came upon underpants on finches… Note to self: read more carefully. 😃
I still call them underpants. I always will.