The American Ornithological Society has committed to changing the English names of birds named after a person, replacing them with more descriptive names, reasoning that many of the people honored by a bird name were unworthy. For example, there is McCown’s Longspur, named after a Confederate general and slavery enthusiast. Some people might be affronted by that association. Others are offended that the name had to be changed, because nothing should change, and people are too damn sensitive. These same people are, by pure coincidence, able to stand in someone’s private field pointing binoculars into the woods without once imagining they’d be rounded up by the constabulary and/or shot.
Anyway, it’s the thick-billed longspur now. Suck it, JoJo.
The good ol’ Great Blue Heron will keep its name on account of its obvious greatness and blueness, but as long as we’re in the mood I’d make a case for Shitepoke. I will probably not prevail because the same term is used for green herons and cormorants and before long you’re calling things the greater shitepoke, lesser shitepoke, and steaming shitepoke, and some evolutionary taxonomist is going to whine about them not being related. Nevertheless, all those birds have a thumpingly enthusiastic waste evacuation system; one good stream from a Namibian heron could knock down a whole family of meerkats in one strafe.
I will have to learn to live without the Brewster’s Warbler, which was not named after me, but well before me. These days, you can forget getting a bird named after you unless your name is Olive, Rufous, or Flammulated.
The idea is to get rid of all eponymous names, even if they refer to perfectly okay historical personages, just to keep things on the up and up and reduce conflict. I will miss the Blackburnian Warbler. It is one of the few birds named after a woman and she wasn’t icky at all. Anna Blackburne was a botanist, primarily, but she did collect other natural items, such as the bird skins her brother sent her from America. That’s how ornithologists used to study birds: by shooting them so they can get a good closeup view. Anna sent her deceased bird to a bird expert and he, rather than naming it the Bullet-Riddled Fluffster, decided to name it after Anna. Anna’s hummingbird was named after a whole different Anna, and she’ll probably have to go too. All she did wrong was marry an ornithologist, which at worst makes her ick-adjacent.
I think it’s a swell idea to rename birds for their appearance or behavior, and it could even be helpful in identifying the little bastards. Problem is, people have already proved to be bad at it. The red-bellied woodpecker has a red head, but “red-headed woodpecker” was already taken. Its belly is at best a little soiled-looking. You’re not going to see a ring on a ring-necked duck at all unless you stretch its neck out (not recommended) or it’s dead. The female cowbird has no distinguishing features whatsoever but that’s no reason to name her after a dumpy ungulate. The female black-throated green warbler has no black throat, so she’s basically just being dismissed as a “Mrs.,” and the so-called “green” of either sex would scandalize a parakeet.
All of which makes bird identification even harder for a rank amateur with a brain like a steel colander, such as myself. But in a recent trip to Maine, a state not known for harboring any Invisible Rails, I totally did not see an invisible rail. I’m counting that as a win.
Agreed on the red bellied woodpecker and the ring necked duck being inappropriately named. How about red capped? That name isn’t taken. Or red crowned. Works for either sex (the female RBW has gray frontals, whereas the male’s red cap goes almost to his beak. The ring necked duck has a very striking ring around the tip of its bill, so ring billed makes more sense.
Whoever named the wood duck way back when had a serious lack of imagination. Yeah, I know, they nest in hollow trees, but folks, the male is one of the gaudiest ducks in North America!
At least (as far as I know) only the common names are being changed for birds. North American frogs, toads and tree frogs are getting their genus names changed.
They’re all trying to get in good with the DAR.
Ornithologically speaking, I have a pet peeve with the red-bellied woodpecker, too. (Not the bird itself. The nomenclature.) The most obvious thing about it is its red head! The belly is pink at best.
Maybe people should just learn a little Latin and call them by their proper names.
And don’t get me started on “parakeets!” It is about as specific as calling any green parrot an Amazon, or any white one, a Cockatoo. There are many varieties. There are several species of parakeets. But what most people refer to as parakeets are Budgerigars — or Budgies. But when I refer to them as budgies, I get a blank look from most people. Yeah… I get that a lot. I’m used to it by now.
Turns out red crowned woodpecker is taken by a tropical woodpecker. If you look it up, it appears to be identical to our red bellied woodpecker. WTF?
Could we rename tits and boobies?
Whoever named the Great Tit had far too much fun.
I think boobies were so named for their comical appearance and habits, boobie in this case meaning fool. Be curious to see when boob and boobie became other words for breast.
Looked it up. Boob meaning fool goes back to 1907. Boobies meaning breasts goes back at least to the 16th century and is probably derived from bubby, which in turn may be derived from a French word or a Latin word.
So why the hell are boobies the bird called that?
I know that some Eastern European people call their grandmothers “Bubby” or “Baba.” (I’m Polish, so it was “Baba.”) Probably a similar etymology as “mama” or “mommy”, which probably stemmed from mammary glands. Women’s roles seemed to be defined by their breasts.
That also explains the fat men in wife-beaters named Bubba.
I certainly renamed mine.
I caught an appearance by Robin Williams on the Craig Ferguson show this morning, yeah, obviously a past appearance. He and Craig were discussing the names they’d given their penises at one point. I played around with that idea with my first girlfriend. The thing certainly seems to have a mind of its own.
So you named it “that idea!”
Hear, hear!
I thought it was your usual hyperbole, but when I looked up “Brewsters Warbler”, this is what I got: “Brewster’s Warbler is an offspring from the Golden-winged Warbler and the Blue-winged Warbler crossbreed.”
I’ll never doubt you again, even if it sends me down a rabbit hole chasing a wild goose on a fool’s mission. If Murr says it, it must have a grain of truth to it!
By the way, that bird doesn’t look the least bit happy about any of this nonsense!
Also, by the by the way (yes I meant that double), the few times I listened to your articles read aloud, I kept thinking, “It’s a shame they didn’t have Murr read them herself!” Then I’d look for the credits of who actually read the piece, and of course would be surprised that it was none other than the person I’d wished they’d used. Your voice just doesn’t seem to “go” with the voice I have of you in my head, despite repeated exposure to it!
I’ve heard that a few times! I think my voice is lower than people expect. And definitely it’s lower than it used to be. I never smoked. I think my voice is just trying to follow my boobies. Also, you said it exactly right: If Murr said it, it must have a GRAIN of truth in it.
One of the perks for women and men is our voices deepen over time. I went from a boy soprano to baritone overnight. I’m a sleepwalker. When I was in the sixth grade my brother and I were camping in a tent. He woke up during the night to find me trying to claw my way out the side of the tent. He made the mistake of trying to wake me and I started screaming my head off. It went on long enough that I woke up the owner of the campground who was convinced someone was being murdered.
I finally woke up with a bunch of flashlights shining in my eyes and a sore throat. I had laryngitis for two weeks and when my voice finally came back, I was a baritone. My voice never broke after that apparently because my vocal cords had been so stretched.
I have a rather deep voice for a woman, and I love it! I deliberately deepen it even more when I pick up the phone when I don’t recognize the number. People would sometimes skip a beat and then say, “Paul???”
Jiminy, Bruce–I think you have way too much you to fit into one person or one lifetime!